5. Written Assignment: Ethical Issue Concept Map and Summary:
Develop a Concept Map diagramming an ethical issue with legal implications and write a summary of the ethical issue.
Directions:
1. Read the article, “Ethical Frameworks” which details the four principles of biomedical ethics a framework developed by Beauchamp and Childress Ethical Frameworks Article (linked under Assignments and Guidelines: Concept Map). Also, review textbook Chapter 22, Ethics and Values, for additional insight.
2. Choose one of the ethical case studies to complete the Concept Map assignment and determine which of the ethical issues/moral principles you have read about that need to be considered when examining this case study (Case Studies in D2L Week 6 Module: Ethics and Values and under Assignments and Rubrics Tab).
3. Refer to the American Nurses’ Association (ANA) Code of Ethics and select which of the nine provisions cover the issues you are discussing (Select a minimum of two of the nine provisions). Incorporate the four principles of the biomedical ethics, and at least two of the nine provisions into a concept map.
4. Create an Ethical Issue Concept Map (a few examples available in D2L) and a Concept Map Written Summary. Both parts of this assignment are to be typed. Be sure and connect the concepts you choose with lines or overlapping boxes to show the connections in the pictorial Concept Map.
5. Use APA format for in-text citations of references in the Concept Map AND in the Written Summary. References are expected in both parts of this assignment. Be sure and submit a reference page.
6. Submit Concept Map and Written Summary as one document to appropriate D2L Dropbox with that name by designated due date in Course Calendar.
NRSE 3400 Concepts of Professional Nursing Practice
Ethical Issue Concept Map and Written Concept Map Summary Grading Rubric
Criteria Excellent
2 points Good
1.5 points
Acceptable
1 point
Needs Improvement
0.5 points
Unacceptable
0 points
Concept Map Demonstrates full understanding of assigned material: Includes all four (4) Biomedical Ethical Principles in the Ethical Issue Concept Map pictorial format AND
Two (2) of the nine ANA provisions
AND Concept Map reflects in-text citations of at least one (1) evidence-based reference and one additional resource (should be textbook, and/or required journal article by Beauchamp and Childress). Demonstrates full understanding of assigned material: Includes a minimum of three (3) of the four Biomedical Ethical Principles in the Ethical Issue Concept Map pictorial format AND a minimum of One (1) of the nine ANA provisions AND
Concept Map reflects in-text citations of at least one (1) evidence-based reference and one additional resource (textbook and/or required journal article by Beauchamp and Childress. Demonstrates full understanding of assigned material: Includes a minimum of two (2) of the four Biomedical Ethical Principles in the Ethical Issue Concept Map pictorial format AND a minimum of One (1) of the nine ANA provisions AND
Concept Map reflects in-text citations of at least one (1) evidence-based reference and one additional resource (textbook and/or required journal article by Beauchamp and Childress. Demonstrates partial understanding of assigned material: Includes only one (1) of the four Biomedical Ethical Principles into the Ethical Issue Case Study in a Concept Map pictorial format AND/OR
None of the ANA provisions AND
Concept Map does not reflect in-text citations of any evidence-based reference, except for textbook or required journal article by Beauchamp and Childress. Concept Map pictorial is not reflective of any of the Biomedical Ethical Principles or ANA provisions applied to the Ethical Issue Concept Map
AND/OR
Has no supporting references from any source
Concept Map Written Summary Demonstrates full understanding of assigned material by including all four (4) Biomedical Ethical Principles into the Concept Map Written Summary AND
Two (2) of the nine ANA provisions.
Reflects in-text citations of at least one (1) evidence-based reference and one additional resource (should be textbook, and/or required journal article by Beauchamp and Childress). Demonstrates full understanding of the assigned material by Including a minimum of three (3) of the four Biomedical Ethical Principles into Concept Map Written
Summary AND a minimum of One (1) of the nine ANA provisions; Reflects in-text citations of at least one (1) evidence-based reference and one additional resource (textbook and/or required journal article by Beauchamp and Childress.
Demonstrates full understanding of the assigned material: Includes a minimum of two (2) of the four Biomedical Ethical Principles into Concept Map Written Summary AND a minimum of One (1) of the nine ANA provisions; Reflects in-text citations of at least one (1) evidence-based reference and one additional resource (textbook and/or required journal article by Beauchamp and Childress. Demonstrates partial understanding of assigned material: Includes only one (1) of the four Biomedical Ethical Principles into Concept Map Written Summary AND/OR None of the ANA provisions;
Written Summary does not reflect in-text citations of any evidence-based reference, except for textbook or required journal article by Beauchamp and Childress. Concept Map Written Summary is not reflective of any of the Biomedical Ethical Principles applied to the Concept Map
AND/OR
Has no supporting references from any source
Quality of Concept Map Concept Map pictorial is clearly designed and legible.
Connections are demonstrated pictorially between the Ethical Issue and the Biomedical Ethical Principles and ANA provisions chosen (either lines are drawn or boxes overlap).
Concept Map pictorial is clearly designed and legible.
Some connections are demonstrated pictorially between the Ethical Issue and the Biomedical Ethical Principles and the ANA provision(s) chosen, but not all.
Concept Map pictorial is clearly designed and legible, however, there are no clear connections (no lines drawn or overlapping boxes) pictorially between the Ethical Issue and the Biomedical Ethical Principles and the ANA provision chosen.
The Concept Map pictorial is submitted, but not legible, with not clear connections pictorially. The Concept Map does not reflect any of the Biomedical Ethical Principles
Quality of Written Summary Concept Map Written
Summary is organized, relevant, and fully depicts the relationships between the Biomedical Ethical Principles, the ANA provisions, and the Ethical Case Study.
Concept Map Written Summary is thoughtful and appropriate
depicting most of the relationships between the Biomedical Ethical Principles, the ANA provisions, and the Ethical Case Study. Concept Map Written Summary is thoughtful and appropriate; lacks depth, not fully depicting the relationship between the Biomedical Ethical Principle, ANA provision, and the Ethical Case Study. Concept Map Written Summary is disorganized, and lacks depth. The Concept Map Written Summary does not reflect an of the Biomedical Ethical Principles
APA skills: in-text citations and reference page and English skills (spelling, grammar, punctuation, sentence structure) No errors
with APA in-text citations or references and/or with English skills including spelling, grammar, punctuation, and sentence structure. One (1) one to two (2) errors with APA in-text citations or references and/or with English skills including spelling, grammar, punctuation, and sentence structure. Three (3) to four (4) errors in APA in-text citations or references, and/or English skill errors, including spelling, grammar, punctuation, and sentence structure Five (5) or more errors in APA in-text citations or references, and/or English skill errors, including spelling, grammar, punctuation and sentence structure. . NA-Missing
.
